Thursday, May 13, 2010

Post Trial Reflection

1. Summarize the facts of the case, as presented by the prosecution. Include relevant witnesses and testimony.
 John Adams, James Madison, and  Raul Grijalva were witnesses for the prosecution. They emphasized the Bill of Rights and original Constitution written by our forefathers. They deemed the State of Arizona to be guilty for violating the spirit of the Bill of Rights through AZ SB 1070 and HB 2162.

2. Summarize the facts of the case, as presented by the defense. Include relevant witnesses and testimony.
 Witnesses included the governor of Arizona Jan Brewer, Kenneth Collins, and Russell Peters. The defense presented murder crimes committed by these illegal immigrants and the fact that they are not citizens, so therefore they do not have the same rights as one.

3. What was the most significant piece of evidence, in your personal opinion?
The most significant piece of evidence was the Bill of Rights. The prosecution emphasized the wording of how the Constitution was written, therefore leaving the Defense helpless.

4. What was the most significant argument made, in your opinion?
 That on the Bill of Rights, it includes all people who commit crime on U.S. soil. Especially since they brought a writer to clarify what was meant to be implied by the writing.

5. What do you personally believe the correct verdict should be? Do you agree with the jury? Why or why not?
Personally, I believe the defense should not be pronounced guilty. However, the jury made the right decision based on the trial that took place today. I deem the defense is not guilty because I agree with all the arguments set forth by Russell Peters. The same rights do not apply to those that are not citizens, and "Mexican" immigrants should have to go through the same process as other immigrants. Also, "Mexican illegal aliens" are taking away jobs that should be of moderate pay.


I think I deserve a 47 out of 50 points because I reported every action that went on during the trial. I did the following things very well: I listed all people and events involved with trial and I was accurate with what I stated. Also, I was present the whole time of the trial, so I know what happened.  Many people were absent between the two day time span of the trial. I could have done better at specifying thoughts and quotes from our witnesses and lawyers by including them into my post.

Twitter 05-13

prosecution: the people of the united states
defense: state of arizona
the count: violating the spirit of the united states's immigrant history through AZ SB1070 and HB 2162

continuation, day 2

10:56am - day 2 begins
10:58am - james madison called to witness stand by aguirre; discusses declaration of independence
11:03am - defense turns down crossexamination of madison
11:04am - aguirre asks follow up questions; objection of ''lack of knowledge'' called
11:06am - witness dismissed; witness jan brewer called to witness stand by mendoza
11:09am - objection of ''material'' called
11:10am - brewer questioned by roesner
11:12am - crossexamined by brown; objection of ''harrassment'' called
11:17am - questioned by aguirre
11:20am - questioned by brown
11:24am - questioned by aguirre
11:26am - questioned by brown
11:27am - witnes jan brewer dismissed; senator russell peters called to witness stand; discusses immigration with identification
11:32am - crossexamined by brown
11:39am - questioned by roesner; witness dismissed
11:40am - kenneth collins called to witness stand by roesner
11:43am - collins crossexamined by brown; discusses experiences with criminals who murdered
11:45am - objection of ''speculation'' called
11:49am - questioned by mendoza; discusses racial profiling
11:50am - trial on break

12:45pm - trial resumes
12:46pm - closing statement by lawyer brown
12:50pm - closing statement by lawyer roesner
12:54pm - jury deliberation
1:30pm - court resumes

Wednesday, May 12, 2010

Twitter Posts of Trial 05-12

prosecution: the people of the united statess
defense: the state of arizona
the convict: wiolating the spirit of the united states's immigrant history through AZ SB 1070 and HB 2162


12:30pm - court gathers
12:39pm - lawyer brown speaks
12:45pm - lawyer roesner speaks. argues for
12:49pm - james madison is pulled to the witness stand by brown;  madison believes constitution was violated
12:52pm - madison is crosswitnessed by roesner; roesner makes mistakes in her questioning
12:54pm - john adams called to witness stand; questioned by lawyer aguirre; boston massacre is discussed
12:58pm - adams is crossexamined by roesner
1:01pm - followup questions to adams by aguirre; adams believes constitution was violated as well; confusion between witnesses being called up
1:04pm - madison called to witness stand once again by aguirre; explains amendments
1:06pm - madison questioned by roesner; the defense's witness does not comprehend questioning
1:10pm - brown questions madison
1:12pm - raul x-x is called to witness stand by aguirre
1:18pm - raul x-x is crossexamined by lawyer mendoza
1:19pm - x-x questioned by roesner
1:22pm - x-x questioned by aguirre
1:23pm - final witness dismissed
1:24pm - court intermission
1:37pm - court resumes
1:39pm - adams recalled to witness stand; brown confuses questions
1:47pm - adams crossexamined by mendoza
1:49pm - 5 minute break requested by brown
1:50pm - judge orders trial to be recalled may 13, 2010

Monday, May 03, 2010

Optional Assignment 5/3

Kurt Vonnegut is often compared to Mark Twain. Some perceive Vonnegut to be the best satirist since the 19th century. They both used humor to attack questions about life and human nature. Additionally, the two authors used much pessimism in their writing. Vonnegut always tried to include humor when he wrote, even though he would not always feel that at the time.

http://popwatch.ew.com/2007/04/12/vonnegut_obitua/

http://www.nytimes.com/2007/04/12/books/12vonnegut.html



http://www.thenation.com/classroom/paks/pakKurt_Vonnegut_in_The_Nation.mhtml

I find it interesting that Vonnegut's writing expands to such wide lengths in variety from Cold War politics to babies to religion. He was fond of science fiction, particularly space travel, time machines, robotics, chemical warfare, and environmental apocalypse. His writing differed with others' with his puncuation and structure.